Duverger, Maurice: No Europe without Germany
Pas d’ Europe sans d’Allemagne , Le Monde, 9 Sept. 1947 (slightly abridged).
From W.Lipgens and W. Loth, Documents on the History of European Integration, De Gruyter, 1988
When Europe is being reconstructed under the Marshall Plan, Germany is not represented at the sixteen-nation conference; when Germany is being reconstructed under the aegis of General Clay, the Sixteen are not consulted and there is no representation of Europe. Can it be that the French are not the only nation to be ‘ignorant of geography’ and that the Americans are no better in this respect than we, in spite of the progress made of late by their geopoliticians? Germany is part of Europe, and one cannot be rebuilt without the other. Without German industry, Europe can only be an American colony; without the hope of belonging to Europe, Germany can only dream of revenge or fall into a nihilistic mood that would throw her, and Europe along with her, into the arms of Russia. The destinies of Germany and Europe are irrevocably linked, and Europe cannot be reborn without Germany.
‘The rebirth of Germany’ – I pondered over this word and hesitated for a long time before writing it, knowing as I do what distress and indignation it will arouse in many minds. The name of Germany is associated, for us in France, with so many deaths, so much suffering, humiliation and grief. Is it not a supreme act of madness on the victim’s part to enable the would-be murderer to grow strong again?
But I would ask my readers to stifle their resentment, justified though it may be, and consider the question without any kind of passion: for it is too serious to be approached in any but the calmest spirit.
Germany exists. Seventy million human beings live in a narrow space between the Elbe and the Rhine. They are hard-working, brave and prolific. One solution, of course, would be to destroy them: no doubt this could be done with a few well-placed atom bombs. But it may be doubted not only whether this is a moral policy, but also whether it is realistic: for it would be hard to know who should take over German territory, or how it should be re- peopled. A third world war might well be the price of solving this question. Therefore Germany must continue to exist, whether we like it or not.